711 Margaret Street, Jacksonville, FL 32204
Twitter Facebook LinkedIn GooglePlus YouTube

Jacksonville Property Management Blog

Seasonal Renting in Florida: Pros and Cons of Short-Term vs. Long-Term Leases
Tanya Douglas
Season Renting in Florida

Seasonal Renting in Florida: Pros and Cons of Short-Term vs. Long-Term Leases

Seasonal renting in Florida has become an increasingly popular choice for property owners and renters. Florida attracts visitors worldwide with its warm climate, beautiful beaches, and endless recreational opportunities. Whether you are a property owner looking to maximize your rental income or a renter seeking a temporary escape from the cold, understanding the pros and cons of short-term versus long-term leases is essential. This article will explore each lease type's unique benefits and challenges to help you make an informed decision.

1. The Appeal of Seasonal Renting in Florida

Florida's appeal as a destination for seasonal renting is undeniable. The state's mild winters and sunny weather make it a prime location for those looking to escape harsher climates. Not to mention, Florida boasts a wide range of attractions, from theme parks like Disney World and Universal Studios to natural wonders like the Everglades and the Florida Keys. The lifestyle benefits of living in Florida, even temporarily, include access to beautiful beaches, golf courses, and vibrant cultural scenes. These factors make seasonal renting in Florida an attractive option for many.


2. Defining Short-Term and Long-Term Leases

Before diving into the pros and cons, it's important to understand what constitutes short-term and long-term leases. A short-term lease typically lasts under six months. These leases are common in vacation rentals and are often used by tourists or seasonal workers. On the other hand, a long-term lease generally lasts six months or longer. Long-term leases are more common in residential rentals and are preferred by individuals looking for more stability.

3. Pros of Short-Term Leases

One of the main advantages of short-term leases is flexibility. For tenants and landlords, short-term leases offer the freedom to adapt to changing circumstances. Tenants can enjoy a temporary stay without a long-term commitment, while landlords can adjust rental prices based on market demand. Besides, short-term leases can generate higher rental income, especially during peak tourist seasons. Properties in desirable locations can command premium rates, significantly boosting revenue. Another key point is that short-term leases often result in less wear and tear on the property since tenants do not stay long enough to cause significant damage.

4. Cons of Short-Term Leases

Short-term leases are not without their downsides. One of the biggest challenges is the higher turnover rate. Frequent tenant changes mean more time and effort spent on marketing, screening, and preparing the property for new occupants. That can be particularly taxing for landlords, but utilizing professional movers can alleviate some stress. They help quickly and safely move furniture and belongings, essential in protecting them from the weather. That is important in places like Florida, where humidity can damage items in no time. Best Movers in Florida can be an excellent choice in such instances. Their platform connects you with professional moving companies with extensive history and experience. They offer a range of services from local to long-distance moves, ensuring that your furniture and belongings are handled carefully and efficiently. With their expertise, you can mitigate the negative aspects of short-term leases and ensure a smooth transition between tenants.

In addition, short-term leases can lead to increased management and maintenance costs. Properties must be kept in top condition to attract renters, which can be expensive and time-consuming. Another concern is the potential for more frequent vacancies. During off-peak seasons, finding tenants can be difficult, leading to periods of no rental income.

5. Pros of Long-Term Leases

Long-term leases, in contrast, offer several advantages. The most significant benefit is stable and consistent income. With a long-term lease, landlords can rely on regular monthly rent payments, providing financial stability. Further, long-term leases reduce vacancy rates. Once a tenant is secured, there is no need to search for new renters constantly. This stability can save landlords time and money. Also, long-term leases tend to have lower management and marketing costs. With fewer tenant turnovers, there is less need for frequent advertising and property preparation. Easier tenant relationships and communication are another advantage. Long-term tenants are likelier to care for the property and develop a good relationship with the landlord.

6. Cons of Long-Term Leases

Nevertheless, long-term leases also come with their own set of challenges. One major drawback is the lack of flexibility for landlords to adjust rent. Rental rates are typically locked in for the duration of the lease, which can be a disadvantage if market rates increase. Similarly, long-term leases can lead to prolonged vacancies between tenants. If a tenant leaves, finding a new one may take longer, resulting in lost rental income. Also, evicting a long-term tenant can be difficult if issues arise. Legal processes can be lengthy and complicated. Over time, wear and tear on the property can accumulate, leading to higher maintenance costs when the lease ends.

7. Unique Tips for Choosing the Right Lease Type

Choosing between short-term and long-term leases depends on various factors. One important consideration is the location of the property and its seasonal demand. Properties in high-demand tourist areas may benefit more from short-term leases. Assessing your financial goals and risk tolerance is also important. A long-term lease might be more suitable if you prefer a stable income with lower risk. On the other hand, short-term leases could be the way to go if you are willing to take on more management responsibilities for higher potential earnings.

Evaluating your ability to manage frequent tenant turnover is also essential. Short-term rentals require more hands-on management. For instance, if you need to move your rental business to Jacksonville and hire movers for your rentals, having a trustworthy crew in Jacksonville can make the process smoother and ensure tenant transitions are handled efficiently. Jacksonville movers can help streamline these transitions by efficiently handling the physical tasks associated with tenant turnover. That includes moving furniture, setting up rooms according to specific layouts, and ensuring all items are in place for new tenants. With a professional moving crew, you can ensure that these changes are carried out swiftly and smoothly, minimizing downtime between tenants and maintaining a high standard of service. This reliability is crucial in sustaining tenant satisfaction and operational efficiency in short-term rentals.

Finally, think about the legal implications and local regulations. Some areas have strict rules regarding short-term rentals that could impact your decision.

8. Financial Considerations for Seasonal Renting in Florida

Comparing the average rental income for short-term versus long-term leases is important regarding financial considerations. Short-term rentals can generate higher income during peak seasons, but this income can be inconsistent. Long-term leases provide steady and predictable income, making it easier to budget and plan. Tax implications should also be considered. Rental income from short-term leases may be subject to different tax rates and regulations than long-term leases. Highlight any potential cost savings or expenses unique to each option. For example, long-term leases might save on marketing costs, while short-term leases could incur higher cleaning and maintenance expenses.


Seasonal renting in Florida presents opportunities and challenges for property owners and renters alike. Understanding the pros and cons of short-term versus long-term leases is essential for making an informed decision. You can choose the lease type that best suits your needs by considering location, financial goals, and management capabilities. Whether you opt for the flexibility and higher potential income of short-term leases or the stability and lower turnover of long-term leases, aligning your choice with your personal and financial objectives will ensure a successful rental experience.

Meta: Explore the pros and cons of short-term vs. long-term leases for seasonal renting in Florida. Make the best choice for your rental strategy.

Kw: Seasonal Renting in Florida




  • New Contruction
  • Season Renting in Florida
  • Home Buying Tips for Snowbirds
  • Transition of Moving to a New Area
  • Renting with Pets
  • Moving into a Sight-Unseen Home
  • Temporary Residence When Moving
  • Pet Statistics
  • Renters Toolkit
  • Senior Friendly Communities
  • Stage your home for a quick and profitalbe sale
  • Mastering the Art of DIY Home Inspections
  • Buying Off-Market Properties
  • The Real Estate Language
  • Finding your dream Home
  • The Art of Home STaging
  • Selling a home
  • Safety
  • Buying a new home
  • Ways a Fence can Enhance Your Outdoor Space
  • Warning Signs You Need a New Real Estate Agent
  • Biggest Benefits of Selling Your Home Discreetly
  • Buyer Remorse
  • 6 projects that can ruin your home's value
  • Key Things to Negotiate When Buying a Home
  • Curb Appeal
  • Moving to Jacksonville
  • Buying a House
  • Renting with Roommates
  • 7 Easy Rental Upgrades
  • Retire in Jacksonville, FL
  • Nursing Homes in Florida
  • Why Jacksonville is Perfect for Young Professionals
  • Pets in a rental property
  • Fall Maintenance Tips
  • Good Property Manager
  • Rental Property Renovations
  • Furnished vs. Unfurnished Rentals
  • Prevent Tenant Damage
  • Tips for Landords
  • 7 Reasons Why Renting Could be Better
  • Attract Quality Tenants
  • How Sober Living House Can Add Value to a Neighborhood
  • Tenant-Proof your rental
  • How to Maintain a Good Relationship With Your Tenants
  • Best Long Distance Moving Companies
  • 7 Best Long-Distance Moving Companies
  • Top 6 Jacksonville Area Suburbs for Young Families
  • House Hunting Tips after you Retire
  • Why Jacksonville is one of the best places to live in the US
  • Tips for Long-Distance Apartment Hunting
  • Most Popular Jacksonville Neighborhoods
  • 6 signs it’s time to replace your HVAC system
  • COVID 19
  • Property Management Education
  • Rental Property Maintenance in Jacksonville
  • Landlord Tenant Law
  • Tenant Eviction
  • Rental Maintenance
  • Rent Collection
  • Security Deposits
  • Setting the Right Rental Price
  • Getting Rent Ready
  • Company
  • How to Evaluate the Quality of Construction in a New Home
  • Seasonal Renting in Florida: Pros and Cons of Short-Term vs. Long-Term Leases
  • Home Buying Tips for Snowbirds Moving to Their Favorite Winter Destination
  • How to Choose a Home that Eases the Transition of Moving to a New Area
  • Renting with Pets in Flordia
  • Tanya Douglas
  • Tonya Douglas
  • Emma Williams
  • Nessa Brown
  • East Coast Haul
  • Old Republic Home Warranty
  • Wanda